#216: Why You Can Make High-Stakes Decisions at Work But Can't Answer "What Do You Want?"
You already asked your husband, your mom, and your group chat what they would do in your situation. And somehow, five opinions later, you’re even less sure what you want. If you find yourself wondering, “Why do I second-guess every decision?” you probably don’t need another decision-making hack. You need to stop requiring your answer to come with a guarantee.
I spent 22 years as a pediatrician making high-stakes decisions where waiting for perfect certainty wasn't an option. But in my own life, I could still second-guess decisions that were nowhere near life-or-death. And after coaching other accomplished women through this same pattern, I've noticed something important: when you say, “I don't know what I want,” that often isn't the whole story.
A lot of the time, you do know. What you don't know is whether you're allowed to choose it, whether it's the “right” answer, or whether you can handle what happens next. In this episode, we'll explore what it actually means to trust yourself so you can move forward with your choices based on what you know and want today, without needing to predict exactly how things will turn out.
Since you’re ready to become your favorite version of you, book a consult to learn more about working with me as your coach.
"The goal is not to become a woman who never makes a choice she later changes. The goal is not to eliminate regret. It is not to make sure everyone approves. And it is definitely not to poll five people until one of them finally says the thing you wanted permission to hear. The goal is to trust yourself to know what you want, state it out loud, make decisions toward that want—and trust yourself to deal with whatever happens next.”
What you'll learn in this episode:
Why your fear of an outcome does not automatically mean you don’t know what you want
How to tell if you’re delaying a decision because you want more information or because you want a guarantee
How to stop treating your preferences like claims you have to prove
Why someone's disagreement with your decision is not evidence that you made the wrong choice
"You don’t have to trust yourself to predict the future. You have to trust yourself to meet yourself there.”
Mentioned in this episode:
Be sure to sign up for a consult to see if coaching with me is the right fit for you. Join me on a powerful journey to become your favorite you.
Listen to the full episode:
Watch the video:
Read the full episode transcript
Hey, this is Melissa Parsons, and you are listening to the Your Favorite You Podcast. I'm a certified life coach with an advanced certification in deep dive coaching. The purpose of this podcast is to help brilliant women like you with beautiful brains create the life you've been dreaming of with intentions. My goal is to help you find your favorite version of you by teaching you how to treat yourself as your own best friend.
If this sounds incredible to you and you want practical tips on changing up how you treat yourself, then you're in the right place. Just so you know, I'm a huge fan of using all of the words available to me in the English language, so please proceed with caution if young ears are around.
You already asked your husband and then your mom, then you dropped, "What would you do?" in your group chat, and somehow five opinions later you're even less sure of what you want. That contradiction used to be my life, too. I was able to make high-stakes decisions as a pediatrician, but when the decision was about my own life, my own answer was harder to trust. Because there's something very different when the person who has to live with the decision is you, and it's probably not what you have been blaming.
I practiced pediatrics for 22 years. I spent my career making high-stakes decisions where waiting for perfect certainty was not an option, but in my own life, I could second-guess decisions that were nowhere near life or death. And after coaching accomplished women through this exact same pattern, I've noticed something important. When you say, "I don't know what I want," that is often not the whole story. A lot of the time you do know. What you don't know is whether you're allowed to choose it, whether it's the right answer, or whether you can handle what happens after you make the decision.
So if you keep wondering, "Why do I second-guess every decision?" I wanna show you what might actually be happening, because you probably don't need another decision-making hack. You need to stop requiring your answer to come with a guarantee. I wanna talk about why you're waiting for your answer to feel more certain than it does.
One of my clients wanted to work four-day weeks instead of five-day weeks. She knew she wanted it. She also knew that she could get her work done in four days. This was not an efficiency problem. It was not a math problem. It was not a question of whether the schedule could work. But she was still afraid to ask her boss, and this is where so many women tell themselves, "See, I must not really know what I want, because if I really wanted it, wouldn't it feel more certain? Wouldn't there be a huge pull? Wouldn't I just know?" Not necessarily. Sometimes what you want is actually very quiet. It might sound like, "I want to work four days. I want to leave. I wanna ask for more money. I don't wanna host Thanksgiving. I wanna spend this money on myself." The desire may be incredibly simple. It gets loud and confusing when you add everything that might happen because of it. So separate these two questions: What do I want, and what am I afraid will happen if I choose it?
Those are not the same question. Your fear deserves attention, but fear does not automatically mean you don't know what you want. And once you see that, there's another reason you may be constantly second-guessing yourself. You're asking the decision to give you something a decision cannot possibly give you. You're looking for a guarantee that does not exist. I have a client who knew that she could no longer continue in her marriage after repeated infidelity. She knew something had to change, but she was deeply worried about what divorce might mean for her children. Would it make their lives harder? Would they struggle emotionally? Would she look back one day and believe that she had made the wrong choice?
At that point, she wasn't just deciding whether or not to stay married. She was trying to make a decision today that could guarantee how everyone would feel tomorrow, and no decision can do that. I see the same pattern even when the stakes look completely different. Another client knew her child's prestigious school was not a good fit. She could see it. She had real evidence. But changing schools felt huge, so she got opinions and then more opinions, and then she made a pros and cons list for her pros and cons list. I kid you not. Because analysis feels productive. One more conversation, one more article, one more person's opinion, one more list, one more night to sleep on it. We tell ourselves that we're gathering information, but sometimes we're just gathering more time before we have to own a choice. Because eventually every decision reaches a point where no more useful information is available.
My client could not know for certain that the new school would be better for her child until she actually went there. She had to choose first. In her case, changing schools turned out to be the best decision for her family, but she didn't get that information ahead of time. She only got that information by making a decision, and that's what makes this so uncomfortable. You can research your way to informed. You cannot research your way to omniscient. You cannot guarantee that your child will never struggle, and you shouldn't want to anyway. You cannot guarantee that you'll never regret part of a decision. You cannot guarantee that your husband will agree. You cannot guarantee that the new job will be better. You cannot guarantee your future self won't know something that your current self has no idea about.
So instead of asking, "How do I know this is the right decision?" try instead asking, "Do I actually need more information, or am I looking for a guarantee?" Because if it's a guarantee you're looking for, no amount of research is gonna get you there. At some point you have to choose without one. And if you recognize yourself in this, if you've already done therapy, if you've already read the books, listened to podcasts, even mine, and you can explain the pattern but still can't seem to interrupt it when it's happening, I offer complimentary consultations. We can look at where this pattern might be showing up in your life and whether coaching together makes sense. But stay with me, because here's another place where we can hand our decision-making power away. We start treating someone else's opinion as evidence that our opinion is wrong.
So in this situation, you're treating your preferences as claims that you have to prove. Ugh, I know this one personally. I had an excellent career as a pediatrician for 22 years. I loved medicine. I loved taking care of my families, and I wanted to leave medicine to become a life coach. That was a very confusing decision for people who have not done something similar. "Why would you leave something you love, Melissa? Why would you ever leave such a respected career? Why walk away from something you worked so hard to build?" And underneath all of those questions, I had to confront another question of my own. Who was I to want more? Notice what happened there. My preference started to get put on trial. I wanted something different. Other people didn't necessarily understand it, and suddenly their lack of understanding could be seen by me as evidence that I was making a mistake, I was doing something wrong.
But a preference is not a courtroom argument. You don't need 12 exhibits and a closing statement to want something. This happens in smaller ways too, of course. You wanna spend the money, someone else thinks that it's too much to spend. You wanna say no, your mother thinks you should go. You wanna make a career change, your colleague thinks that staying put is the more responsible choice. You think, "I want this," and then someone else gives a different opinion, and suddenly you're back to asking yourself, "Wait, I don't know. Do I?" Their opinion might be useful information. It is not proof that your experience is invalid.
Sometimes your next level of self-trust is simply allowing another adult to disagree with you without immediately turning their disagreement into evidence against yourself. And this brings us to the piece that changes how you make decisions entirely, because self-trust is not about actually getting better at predicting which decision will work out. Self-trust is not trusting that you'll always choose correctly. I have a client who left her hospital system and started a direct primary care practice. That required decision after decision, some big and some small. And unfortunately, she did not become a person who could all of the sudden see the future. That would've been fun and too easy. She had to practice self-trust again and again. She had to make the decision she had made the right decision. I love that distinction, because most of us are trying to identify one correct answer before we make a move. We think self-trust sounds like, "I know this is definitely going to work." It doesn't. Self-trust sounds more like, "Based on what I know today, I'm choosing this, and then if it goes beautifully, I can handle that. If it gets messy, I can also handle that. If I need to change course or pivot, as they say on Friends, I can do that, too.
If I learn something that I did not know before, I will use that as information instead of using it as proof that I should have never trusted myself." That is a very different relationship with decisions, because the goal is not to become a woman who never changes a decision that she's made. The goal is not to eliminate regret. It's not to make sure everyone else approves, and it is definitely not to poll five people until you hear the answer that you've been waiting to hear. The goal is to trust yourself to know what you want, to say it out loud, make decisions toward what you want, and trust yourself to deal with whatever happens next. You don't have to trust yourself to predict the future. You have to trust yourself to meet yourself there.
Hey there. Before you go, I'm doing something different for this launch, and I want you in the room with me. If you're listening to this in the fall of twenty twenty-six, you're in luck. If you're listening from the future, sorry about your luck. Starting Monday, November sixteenth through Thursday, November nineteenth, I'm opening up my coaching Zoom room to any woman who wants to join. I'm calling it Coach Week. Here's how it works:
Each day from eleven thirty AM to one PM Eastern, I'll teach for the first ten to fifteen minutes, and then the rest of the time is yours. Open complimentary coaching live with me. You can come all four days or just the one day you actually need. There's no right way to do Coach Week. The right way is whatever works for you. At the end of each session, I'll tell you a little bit more about what's coming in twenty twenty-seven for my Your Favorite You coaching group because this one's different from anything I've done before. For the first time ever, it includes a five-night retreat in Tulum, Mexico. Yes, Tulum. Yes, you get to come.
The new group kicks off in January 2027, and I cannot wait to share all of it with you. If you want in on Coach Week, and I really hope you do, head to melissaparsonscoaching.com/coachweek to get signed up.
Enjoying the Podcast?
Subscribe by clicking your favorite player below.
If you like what you're hearing so far please take a couple of minutes to leave a 5-star rating and review on Apple Podcasts by clicking here. You'll be my new favorite podcast listener. :)








Comments